Book Review: Random Family, by Adrian Nicole LeBlanc

In Random Family: Love, Drugs, Trouble, and Coming of Age in the Bronx, Adrian Nicole LeBlanc follows the lives of a Dominican-American family living and growing up in the Bronx in the 1980s and 1990s. Jessica, her brother Cesar, and Cesar’s girlfriend Coco face poverty, drugs, children, abuse, and incarceration over the course of a decade or so, and all of it is faithfully reported by LeBlanc. Much like Always Running (review here), Random Family is a sometimes- unpleasant read, but an important one. For many Americans, the effects of extreme, generational poverty are invisible. LeBlanc forces you to look–to care.

First, I very much appreciated that LeBlanc kept herself out of the narrative. I think the tendency to insert oneself into stories like this can be tempting, especially when you are following the same individuals for years, becoming enmeshed in their lives. LeBlanc wisely realized that this book was not about her, but rather, about the lives of Jessica, Coco, and their families. Readers will already recognize that LeBlanc is an outsider to this neighborhood and this culture, and any attempts to include herself more firmly in the narrative would have only highlighted the contrast even more.

The world of Random Family is fascinating–morbidly so. The Bronx of the ’80s and ’90s depicted in this book is, in many respects, an unforgiving place. Gang violence is prevalent, as is gun ownership. Drug use and dealing is merely a way of survival. The cycle of poverty appears unending. Parents are either absent, addicts, abusive, or incarcerated. Everyone suffers. It will weigh very, very heavily on your mind, and you will cheer every time Coco, Jessica, or Cesar make the slightest bit of headway against such overwhelming odds. LeBlanc does a commendable job in making the environment painfully real, even to readers who have never been to the Bronx.

LeBlanc also faithfully shows the love and loyalty that blooms in even the harshest neighborhoods. Social bonds can extend past nuclear families to include friends-of-friends and neighbors, creating the feeling that each block in the Bronx is its own microcosm. There are many instances where families share whatever they can with one another, even if they are barely scraping by: Lourdes, Jessica and Cesar’s mother, for example, happily feeds their friends and neighbors whenever she is able to find groceries to cook. Even distant family members and the mothers of Cesar’s ex-girlfriends find a few dollars to put in his prison commissary. Coco stumbles, but you know that she is trying her best to provide for her children; her missteps are often only the fault of a system that allows people like her–poor, uneducated, a single mother–to slip through the cracks.

And that brings me to my main criticism of Random Family: the lack of meaningful context provided. So many questions are raised by the lived experiences of our family and their friends and acquaintances: Why do young men in the Bronx feel like dealing drugs is their only viable form of employment? Why do sexually-active young couples refuse to use birth control? Why is sexual abuse of young girls so prevalent?

We get some sense of why our main characters choose to do what they do–Coco moves to Troy, for example, to escape from the overwhelming situation at her mother’s apartment, and because her friend Milagros lives there–but we are not afforded a larger sense of the societal and cultural pressures that force those decisions. LeBlanc alludes to institutional oppressions only in the afterward, and only very briefly. And in one of his letters from prison, where he has taken advantage of adult education classes, Cesar tantalizingly says,

Poverty is a subculture that exists within the ghetto. It goes beyond black or Hispanic, at least in my mind. Overworked teachers. Run-down schools. It looks like they designed this system to make our children fail. Socioeconomic conditions. Why are we so passive? We accept conditions that don’t benefit us–economic oppression we’ve been suffering for years.

I don’t think, however, these glimpses of broader societal issues were enough. As a journalist, LeBlanc could have done research into the socioeconomic factors and systemic inequalities that lead to situations like Jessica’s and Coco’s in order to provide a deeper understanding of the limited options available to Bronx youths; and yet, the reader was left to speculate on their own. I think if someone began this book with conservative views, reading Random Family could actually encourage them to decry social programs like SNAP benefits and welfare even more, which is extremely problematic.

One of the more encouraging sections of the book highlighted the efficacy and importance of nonprofit interventions. Coco’s children have the opportunity to go to a summer camp for at-risk youth, and you get the sense that it was transformative for them. Unfortunately, as LeBlanc mentions, initiatives like these are understaffed, underfunded, and of a short duration, with little follow-up once the children return to their homes. Still, in the book, the children’s experiences with nonprofits represent some of the brighter spots in their lives.

That leaves me with my hopes for the novel. I hope that Jessica, Coco, and their families received some of the benefits of the book’s popularity–either some of the money earned from its sale or some assistance from LeBlanc herself. There was no explicit mention of this in the book, and I couldn’t find anything online regarding compensation for the book’s subjects.

I also hope that the readers of Random Family–rather than taking any sort of voyeuristic thrill from the individuals’ lives–use it as an opportunity to examine their own privilege, to volunteer their time and donate their money to nonprofits, to talk to their children about poverty, and to vote for candidates who support social programs. If everyone who had the means to do even one of those things did them, perhaps we would someday have a world where each and every random family had access to good education, healthy food, and a safe environment to raise their children in.

Random Family fulfills one of my choices for the 2013 TBR Pile Challenge, hosted by Roof Beam Reader.

Bookwanderer Rating: Four out of five stars
Bookwanderer Tagline: “They wanted to leave the familiar world behind, but no one knew the direction out.”

Other Reviews: The New York Times, The Guardian, A Good Stopping Point, Books are my Boyfriends

Advertisements

6 Responses to “Book Review: Random Family, by Adrian Nicole LeBlanc”


  1. 1 myfemalepersuasion February 9, 2013 at 2:44 am

    I just finished reading this book per the suggestion of my writing coach, and it was one of the best I’ve read, partly because I grew up in a similar world – in Brooklyn, NY, during the same era. To your criticism of the author, and her lack of explanation for the things you didn’t understand, it’s simple – there are certain things you will never e able to relate to or understand if you haven’t been raised in a ghetto or in poverty. The concepts and experiences will always seem foreign to you. To your comment, “As a journalist, LeBlanc could have done research into the socioeconomic factors and systemic inequalities that lead to situations like Jessica’s and Coco’s in order to provide a deeper understanding of the limited options available to Bronx youths..” where do you think this would have fit in the book? As an essay at the very end? I don’t think there was a place for it. M writing coach is a clinical professor at New York University (a white middle-aged female who grew up privileged) said the concepts were foreign to her as well, but she appreciated the book for its brilliance. LeBlanc’s reporting and storytelling techniques are remarkable. The story is complicated. Way to complicated to address every reader’s potential questions.

    • 2 tarynwanderer February 9, 2013 at 8:09 am

      First, I agree with you that this is a wonderful and compelling book. I criticize because I love! 🙂

      You’re probably right that an essay at the end would have felt too overdone, but I think some exploration of broader societal themes could have been woven throughout the book. There are many nonfiction books out that that manage to integrate specific stories, like Jessica’s or Coco’s, with their relationships to systemic factors; off the top of my head, Susan Orlean’s The Orchid Thief is a good example of what I mean.

      As to whether readers of the book could ever relate to the families…I think that most people that read this book read it exactly because they want to try to understand that world. They want to understand Cesar and Jessica and Coco. And I imagine that at least some of them also want to understand how the Bronx became the Bronx. A discussion of institutional inequities, like redlining and white flight, would have helped readers to put the family’s life in some context. Definitively stating that they will never understand it–when they are reading a book in order to gain insight and understanding!–is a little unfair, but I understand that lived experience differs from academic knowledge.

      Additionally, I was raised in a similar area in Queens–at one point, this neighborhood was processing the most Columbian cocaine in the United States–so I certainly respect your experience growing up in Brooklyn, and Jessica, Cesar, and Coco’s growing up in the Bronx.

      Thanks for your thoughtful comment! Always nice to have discussions like this. 🙂 I’ll be sure to check out your blog, too.

  2. 3 myfemalepersuasion February 9, 2013 at 10:05 am

    Thank you for responding. My point really is this book is meant to be a story and not an explanation. I tried reading Orlean’s book a couple of years ago and as much as I tried, couldn’t make it halfway through the book. I was overwhelmed with details and and about bored to death. We all have preferences as to what’s a good read, and what an author’s shortcomings are.

    • 4 tarynwanderer February 9, 2013 at 10:17 am

      That’s fair enough! I’m glad we both enjoyed Random Family, even if we were coming at it from different points of view. It really was a great read, and if you ever find anything similar to it, please feel free to let me know!

      Thanks again for your thoughtful comments. 🙂

  3. 5 research tool bing June 10, 2015 at 3:37 am

    It’s going to be ending of mine day, but before
    ending I am reading this fantastic article to increase my experience.


  1. 1 Terry Simpson MD Trackback on March 13, 2015 at 10:02 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 125 other followers

Categories

My Goodreads

Blog Archive


%d bloggers like this: